But after a gig left him with a ruptured eardrum, he discovered the music industry was missing a beat and his pastime quickly turned into a full-time career.
"Doctors told me to wear foam earplugs to my next concert," Mann told CNBC Make It. "But after putting them in, I instantly realized they destroyed the sound quality and are not designed for music."
He questioned why there was no better alternative. Though injuries like Mann's are rare, around 440 million people worldwide are at risk of hearing damage due to live entertainment, according to an estimate from the World Health Organization.
So he came up with Vibes, whose line of reusable "hi-fidelity" earplugs lowers high and low frequency sound levels equally, resulting in a more balanced sound than that from traditional earplugs.
According to Mann, that's a big solution to a problem most people don't even know they have.
"It's a really big deal and people aren't very aware of it because it's a gradual decline," said Mann. "You don't wake up deaf one day. It's kind of a chip off a block of ice every time."
"Every time your ears ring, that's irreversible hearing damage," he continued. "That ringing that you're hearing in your ears is those cells dying. There's no way to get that back unless someone invents technology to do otherwise."
As it turned out, someone was listening. Shortly after launching Vibes in late 2016, Mann received an email from Shark Tank's production team who wanted to hear more.
"Being in business only a few months, I literally thought it was spam," recalled Mann.
Nonetheless, he called them straight away.
The producers had seen his earplugs on a music/lifestyle blog and wanted him to apply for the show.
The process was "rigorous," Mann said. Indeed, statistically it's harder to get on "Shark Tank" than it is to get into Harvard University. Of the 45,000 people who apply each year, less than one percent get to pitch to the sharks, while Harvard's acceptance rate this year was 4.6 percent.
But it paid off. Within weeks, Mann was pitching on a national stage to a panel of celebrity investors — an experience he described as "intense" and "incredible."
His 10-minute pitch won the approval of shark Kevin O'Leary, who made him an offer of $100,000 for a 35 percent stake plus $2 for every pair of earplugs sold.
For Mann, however, that deal was too costly for his young business.
"We were only in business for three months by the time we filmed, so it was very early to be giving up that much equity," said Mann, now 29, who is Vibes' sole founder. "Additionally, we weren't fully confident on our price-point at that stage. It was unclear what [impact] $2 royalties would have had."
Mann walked away from the show empty handed, but he said has "no regrets."
By taking the bootstrapping approach and working out of his van, his business has grown from an initial investment of $33,000 to $2 million in sales as of 2017.
The show also provided him with necessary feedback and opened his business up to a whole new audience beyond concertgoers, he said.
From employees at Starbucks coffee roasting plants and U.S. military skydivers to car racing fans and children with autism, the Vibes customer base has grown.
"This feedback was an integral part of understanding how our customers were using our products and gave us confidence to expand beyond concerts," said Mann.
That growth has meant Vibes has been able to give something back. While the company's reusable earplugs retail at $23.99, for every pair purchased, a contribution is given to Hear the World Foundation.
"We really wanted to do something to protect and give other people the ability to hear," said Mann. "In many areas around the world, access to health services is very limited."
A lot of times, a child's hearing loss is not noticed by teachers or doctors. "Because they can't hear, they can't learn very well. They get put in a class with everyone else and they can't really learn and aren't really progressing well in life," said Mann.
"We began this project to protect our customers' hearing and also give the power to people to hear through hearing aid and surgeries."
Disclaimer: CNBC owns the exclusive off-network cable rights to "Shark Tank."
Like this story? Subscribe to CNBC Make It on YouTube!