You're more likely to have your FAFSA verified than to have your taxes audited—here's why

Marko Geber | DigitalVision | Getty Images

Current and prospective college students can now complete the Free Application for Federal Student Aid, known as the FAFSA, for their share of $150 billion in federal student aid — including grants, scholarships, loans and work-study — for the 2022-2023 school year

But confusion around the form leads students to miss out on billions in aid each year and now, experts are calling attention to the ways in which the student aid process can create challenges for students. 

"Anywhere from 17 million to 21 million postsecondary students complete the FAFSA annually," reads a new report titled "The Burden of Proof: Impact of and Solutions for FAFSA Verification" by the National Association of Student Financial Aid Administrators (NASFAA) and the National College Attainment Network (NCAN). "A significant portion of these students cannot receive their aid without completing an additional, lengthy process called verification to confirm that their FAFSA is accurate."

In fact, the researchers say that proportionally, you are more likely to have your FAFSA verified than to have your taxes audited. Here's why:

How verification works

After students submit their FAFSA to the Department of Education, students' information is sent to all institutions the students have listed on their application. 

The Department of Education flags students for verification using an annually adjusted algorithm. Individual colleges and universities are then responsible for conducting each verification process. Students can be asked to verify details such as household size, the number of family members in college, adjusted gross income and/or their high school completion status. 

"In recent years, the U.S. Department of Education (ED) has set goals to decrease overall verification rates. ED verified as much as 38% of FAFSA filers during certain cycles over the past decade. This was down to a low of 17.11% for the first three-quarters of the 2021-22 cycle. Additionally, ED has suspended some types of verification for the remainder of the 2021-22 award year as a way to provide students some relief during the COVID-19 pandemic," reads the report. "But the department has not extended such relief to the 2022-23 FAFSA filing cycle, which began on Oct. 1, 2021."

In December 2020, the Department of Education's Federal Student Aid office announced a new goal to verify 18% of FAFSA applicants. And students who receive Pell Grants (federal scholarship funds given to low-income students) are significantly more likely to be selected for verification. In recent years, as many as 90% of Pell-eligible students were required to verify their FAFSA details. 

"The Department of Education cited as justification for their 18% selection rate that they conducted a cost-benefit analysis and determined that the cost of performing verification exceeds the benefits when it selects more than 18% of FAFSA filers," says Jill Desjean, policy analyst for NASFAA. "The IRS audit rate is much lower (less than 1%), but I don't know their justification for that rate."

The odds of having your taxes audited by the IRS have fallen significantly over the past decade. The agency audited 0.45% of individual tax returns in fiscal year 2019—down more than half from what it was in 2010, when 1.11% of taxpayers were audited. The IRS attributes this drop to budget and personnel reductions.

Source: National College Attainment Network

What students can do 

To avoid what can be a burdensome FAFSA verification process, Desjean says students should create lines of communication with their college's financial aid offices.

"Students should complete the FAFSA accurately and ask the financial aid office if they're having trouble with answering any of the questions," she says. "The same is true if they are selected for verification. They should pay attention to deadlines for institutional and state financial aid, since those vary. And if their circumstances have changed since they completed the FAFSA, or since the tax year the FAFSA applies to, they should reach out to the financial aid office for the possibility of a revision to their financial aid eligibility."

Carrie Warick, director of policy and advocacy at NCAN, says attention to detail is key.

"Students can best benefit from the FAFSA by completing it as accurately as possible, as early as possible, and by sending it to several schools," she says. "Accuracy – students should not estimate, but rather use the IRS Data Retrieval Tool or copy numbers exactly from their tax returns and other financial documents. Early – some financial aid is first-come, first-served. Early completion aids in access to this aid, and also in helping students applying to multiple institutions have time to weigh their options."

Warick adds that aspiring college students hoping to secure the strongest financial aid package should do so by applying to several schools and leveraging offers as a negotiation tool. 

"High school seniors and other first-time college students should apply to at least four institutions so that they have multiple financial aid packages to compare," she says. 

And while the odds of verification may be higher than students might like, putting in the effort to complete the FAFSA is still the best way for students to access the largest source of financial aid in the country.

Don't miss:

How student loans became a $1.6 trillion problem
How student loans became a $1.6 trillion problem