Interest Rates Rising

Why investors keep buying expensive bonds

Leslie Shaffer | Writer for
DNY59 | E+ | Getty Images

It's pretty clear bonds are a bad job, with returns relatively meager and prices likely to fall ahead, but yield-seeking investors keep pushing money their way.

"People have been buying bonds for some years and going further out the risk spectrum to get yield as Treasury yields fall," said Mark Matthews, head of research for Asia at Julius Baer. Bond yields move inversely to their prices. "There's not a lot of value left in fixed income in general, not just the high yield," he said.

"With the Federal Reserve tapering (its asset purchases) and looking to raise rates next year, the price appreciation we've seen generally over the last five years (will reverse) and prices will fall as yields head up," Matthews said.

Read More Red flag waves over junk bonds as money pours into high yield

That hasn't stopped investors from chasing bonds' payouts. So far this year, $56.69 billion has flowed into bond funds, outpacing the $44.06 billion heading into equities, according to data from Jefferies.

All those funds chasing what appear to be ever-smaller yields have kept bonds expensive and sometimes crowded.

"Investment grade credit is trading rich and looks increasingly vulnerable to rising rates," Morgan Stanley said in a note last week. "Upside appears very limited in high yield, and a negative shock (emerging market turmoil, weaker China or domestic growth etc.) is possible."

High-yield debt overvalued: Pro

Others are concerned about the move further out the yield spectrum.

"The yields that you're getting over government bonds have reduced dramatically. We're not at record-tight levels but we're not that far away," Steve Goldman, managing director at Kapstream Capital, a fixed income fund manager with $7 billion under management, told CNBC last week.

"What it's meant that investors are moving toward greater and greater risk in order to pick up slightly higher yields. And you've got to be careful because the quality of the issuance in that high yield or junk space is going down," he added.

Read More Are junk bonds losing their 'high-yield' status?

Just how much risk are investors chasing? The International Finance Corp. (IFC), a World Bank unit, is getting ready to offer local-currency bonds in Rwanda next month. The Rwanda offering will likely be well received, if the reception of the IFC's first offering under its Pan-Africa note program is anything to go by. That issue—of 150 million Zambian kwacha ($24 million) notes in September—was 4.8 times oversubscribed, according to a Bloomberg report.

Rwanda raised $400 million in a 10-year Eurobond bond offering last year, with the yield on the notes due 2023 falling to around 6.7 percent this year. By way of comparison, India's 10-year government bonds due in 2023 are yielding around 8.9 percent.

Read More Retirees brace for rising rates

Even the seemingly "safe" U.S. Treasury segment is seeing some risk chasing. Barclays is advising seeking out "off-the-run" Treasurys, or bonds and notes issued before the most recent paper, to squeeze out around 30 to 56 basis points of extra yield—even though the off-the-run bonds are much less liquid.

"We are comfortable taking some additional liquidity risk to pick up spread," Barclays said in a note last week.

To be sure, not many expect a bond crackup anytime soon.

Is it time to look to the high-yield market?

"A downturn in the current credit cycle seems unlikely and the coupon income of high yield is hard to find elsewhere," the Morgan Stanley note said.

Others point to data from Moody's indicating corporate issuers don't seem to be running into any walls just yet.

"There has not been an increase in the default rate," Julius Baer's Matthews noted. "Cash levels at corporate America are at an all-time high," he said. "The credit metrics are still very robust in the high-yield market. That's why people are still very happy to stay there, even if you don't get paid very much."

Read More Keep bonds but stay alert: Advisors

Richard Harris, CEO at Port Shelter Investment Management agrees that problems at the corporate end don't appear likely, but he's a bit more cautious on sovereign bonds.

"The last few years, corporates have had to toughen up or die," he said. "When interest rates go up, and they will eventually, it's a lot less likely to impact the corporate sector than it is the government sector," he said.

As the euro zone debt crisis has settled down, investors have plowed into peripheral Europe's debt, but "it doesn't mean to say dangers are any less," Harris said, noting the size of interest payments due from the periphery this year alone. The PIIGS, or Portugal, Ireland, Italy, Greece and Spain, will pay some 130 billion euros in interest this year alone, according to calculations from the Financial Times.

Read More Five reasons investors are now loving Greek debt

Yield chasing has led to anomalies in European bonds, such as still-worrisome Spain recently selling five-year government bonds at nearly the same yield as their U.S. Treasury equivalent. The yield for five-year Spanish debt was around 1.68 percent as of Wednesday morning; U.S. Treasurys were around 1.68 percent.

This month, Greece also issued its first long-term bond in four years, with the five-year security attracting 20 billion euros worth of bids. Greece sold around 3 billion euros worth of debt at an around 4.95 percent yield.

"We're likely to see people focus on the growth aspects, rather than the debt aspects," he said, but added "it's still a fragile situation. The overall economy (of Europe) looks good, but that because Germany looks extremely good."

—By CNBC's Leslie Shaffer. Follow her on Twitter @LeslieShaffer1