Asia-Pacific News

Hong Kong power play: who's in control?

HK councilor: Authorities must apologize
HK councilor: Authorities must apologize

Pro-democracy protesters in Hong Kong may have demanded the resignation of the territory's chief executive, CY Leung, but some analysts doubt a change at the top would help in the long term.

Hong Kong's worst period of unrest in decades has captured the attention of the world this week, as pro-democracy protests moved into their seventh day. Demonstrators have threatened to step up protests if Leung has not stepped down by the end of Thursday.

Read MoreHong Kong protests are leaderless but orderly

"If the situation really intensifies, it's possible that there might be some pressure on the chief executive to consider resigning," Nicholas Consonery, China analyst at Eurasia Group told CNBC Asia's "Rundown" on Wednesday.

"And that would probably take the wind out of the sails of the protest movement but it would not address the core issues."

Students march to the Government House in Hong Kong holding a portrait of Chief Executive Leung Chun Ying.
Xaume Olleros | AFP | Getty Images

Organizers of the protest are unhappy with the current electoral system,which at present only allows residents to vote for a pre-approved list of candidates. This makes it impossible for critics of Beijing to get on the ballot. Chinese authorities had promised reform by 2017, but on August 31 decreed that it would continue to vet candidates wishing to run for Hong Kong's leadership.

Much of the anger has been directed toward Leung, a Beijing loyalist who has been in power since mid-2012. Leung was blamed for authorizing the territory's police to use tear gas on the protesters on Sundaya move which has drawn broad criticism considering Hong Kong has not used such severe methods since 2005.

Read MoreIn 'Umbrella Revolution,' China confronts limits of its power

Chants for Leung's resignation have been heard throughout the week's demonstrations. Meanwhile banners depicting Leung with vampire fangs have become a common image throughout. Student protesters have even refashioned a stranded city bus into a coffin for him.

Any concessions to the protesters' demands look unlikely at this stage,however, as Leung is widely regarded as a "stooge" for Beijing authorities, and Chinese authorities are nervous that any sign of weakness could trigger unrest in mainland China.

Read MoreXi Jinping embraces old guard as Hong Kong challenges party rule

But while protesters would likely see Leung's resignation as a symbolic victory in their campaign—with many analysts saying that such a move would be the easiest way for Beijing to placate protesters—there are doubts about how helpful it would be.

"I think it's actually better to keep him there because it's better to know who you have rather than to come up with a new person that is representing the Communist Party in Hong Kong... and then they have to start again," Paul Zimmerman, southern district councilor of Hong Kong, told CNBC on Thursday.

"It's better to find a way of talking and working [together] but CY is now the one who has to pick up the phone and come down to start getting a discussion going," he added.