Strong earnings won't prevent 'Trump rally' from buckling, here's why

  • A top strategist at Russell Investments says the stock market rally could be losing its muscle.
  • Mark Eibel is warning investors that strong earnings are not enough to keep stocks at record levels.

The stock market rally could be losing its muscle.

A top strategist at Russell Investments is warning investors that strong earnings are not enough to keep stocks at record levels — and there's nothing Federal Reserve Chief Janet Yellen or President Donald Trump can do about it.

"We are surprised at the resilience of the U.S. market. We recognize it's been a good earnings season," said Mark Eibel, the firm's director of client investment strategies, on Tuesday's "Futures Now." "You're really kind of banking on earnings staying or improving at this level particularly in light of the Fed raising rates at least one more time this year and until some policy gets through the administration."

Since Trump won the November presidential election, the S&P 500 and the Dow have soared 12 percent and 14 percent, respectively.

The Nasdaq has been the biggest winner. The index has rocketed 17 percent since the election, and broke the 6,000 level for the first time ever last week. It's registered all-time intraday highs 29 times since just Jan. 1.

Wall Street has viewed Trump's business-friendly policies as favorable to stocks and the economy. If the majority of his legislation makes it through Congress, Eibel argues a lot of the gains could already be priced into the market.

"Until some of the promises are fulfilled, you are kind of left with earnings," added Eibel.

"The struggle moving forward from here is we know we are rolling off easy comparables from a year ago particularly in the energy space. So we won't have that moving forward as much through the rest of the year."

Eibel also points to the first quarter's disappointing gross domestic product numbers and softer U.S. consumer spending as catalysts which could slow the rally, and cause stocks to move "sideways" or even "downward."

The most effective way to keep profits growing would be to look abroad, according to Eibel.

"We just seem as if we're priced for perfection here — where around the rest of the globe, you can get the same kind of story. There are politics everywhere. And with an improving political situation in Europe, you get cheaper stocks," he said.

Sign-up for the "Futures Now" newsletter here.


  • Rates are entering a new phase in their cycle: Yamada

    Bonds are entering a new rising rates cycle for the first time in decades. Technician Louise Yamada explains what this means for the market.

  • What's next for the oil market?

    Following a recent correction, Tom Kloza of the Oil Price Information Service tells CNBC's Jackie DeAngelis where crude is headed next.

  • Futures Now, February 15, 2018

    The market's coming back, but one trader isn't buying the bounce. Technician Louise Yamada says this is the next line in the sand for rates. And Oil's back at $60, but Tom Kloza, Oil Price Information Service, says the rally will stall, with CNBC's Jackie DeAngelis and the Futures Now traders.

Host Bio & Watch Now

Trader Bios