Personal Finance

What the lawsuit against Navient means for your student loans

Key Points
  • The Pennsylvania Attorney General's office accuses Navient of selling "risky and expensive subprime loans."
  • Consumers should brush up on the terms of their existing loans and read the fine print before taking on new ones.
Pennsylvania AG files suit against student loan provider Navient

Your student loan servicer may not have your best interest at heart. And that means you need to be vigilant.

The Pennsylvania Attorney General's office on Thursday filed a lawsuit against Navient, now the largest student loan servicer in the U.S. and formerly part of Sallie Mae. The suit alleges the company "harmed countless student loan borrowers" by "peddling risky and expensive subprime loans that they knew or should have known were likely to default."

"The allegations are completely unfounded and the case was filed without any review of Pennsylvania residents' customer accounts," Navient said in a statement.

National student loan debt has climbed to $1.4 trillion as of 2017, according to the tracker Student Loan Report. The average debt per student borrower is now $27,857, and the student loan default rate is 10.7 percent.


For existing borrowers, there likely isn't any immediate action needed, said Mark Kantrowitz, publisher and vice president of strategy at, a provider of data on colleges, admissions and scholarships. "If you haven't experienced any problems with them, then there isn't any reason to switch," he said.

Kantrowitz recommends that any borrower who encounters problems with their servicer to reach out to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.

"The lenders tend to be really responsive to complaints received on the CFPB," Kantrowitz said. "It's not always going to be in your favor, but they will respond."

Here's how many complaints student loan servicers have received so far in 2017, according to The Student Loan Report.

Student loan servicer complaints for federal and private loans

Servicer Federal Complaints Private Complaints Total Complaints
PHEAA (FedLoan & AES)8372081,045
Great Lakes19618214
Granite State549
OSLA Servcing505

Source: Source: The Student Loan Report

The Navient suit highlights the need for borrowers to carefully assess their decisions.

Moving your loan

Borrowers who are experiencing problems with their lender may not qualify to move their loan to another lender, Kantrowitz said. That's because problems often arise after borrowers have missed payments, and changing lenders generally requires a borrower to have excellent credit.

If a move to a different lender will not work, student loan borrowers can take other measures. For example, a borrower's parents can take out a home equity loan, Kantrowitz said. The student could then use that money to pay off the student loan and pay back the parents' loan.

"The cons are now you put your parents' home at risk," Kantrowitz said. "If you default on a student loan, you can't lose your education."

Borrowers who plan to stay with their current servicing company should also take steps to protect themselves.

Is forbearance an option?

First, know what your options are, said Betsy Mayotte, director of consumer outreach and compliance at American Student Assistance, a nonprofit that helps students understand the college financing process.

Forbearance, or getting a temporary repayment delay on your loan, for example, should be a last resort, because interest continues to accrue and often ends up augmenting the loan balance unless a borrower continues to make payments on the interest.

Student loans will drag on the economy: Expert

"Go into that phone call informed in the first place and make sure that person is as informed as they can be so they can pick the best option for you," Mayotte said. That includes reading your promissory note, familiarizing yourself with your loan holder's website and checking U.S. Department of Education website

Doug Boneparth, a financial advisor and president at Bone Fide Wealth, also recommends that borrowers request an amortization schedule from their lender, which will show when the loan will be paid off according to the current repayment schedule.

Students should also think carefully before taking out a loan in the first place, Mayotte said.

"You don't want to take a loan if they have an insanely high interest rate or terms that aren't favorable," she said. "If you can't find a loan with favorable terms, it's OK to go to another school."