Foot Locker, up 22 percent, was the most actively traded among stocks listed on the New York Stock Exchange.
Brokerages including Jefferies and Wedbush raised their price targets on Shoe Carnival's shares by $2 to $22 and $27, respectively, as they expect improved performance in 2018.
"It is clear to us the SCVL team is managing its business exceptionally well. SCVL's willingness to plan purchases appropriately (boots are planned down 10 percent for the season) resulted in inventory levels down 4.3 percent on a per-store basis at 3Q17-end," Susquehanna analyst Sam Poser said.
The strong results come as bankruptcies of peers such as Sports Authority, Sports Chalet and changing shopping habits of consumers in favor of e-commerce websites have forced sporting goods retailers to slash prices to clear out the excess stockpile of inventory.
Shoe Carnival and Hibbett raised their full-year comparable store sales forecasts.
Shoe Carnival's third-quarter same-store sales jumped 4.4 percent, much higher than the 0.4 percent increase in the second quarter.