×

Square shares plunge 16% after analyst says bitcoin-related rally masking company's real risks

  • One Wall Street analyst downgrades Square, citing an "overdone" rally and worries of tying the company's success to volatile bitcoin.
  • "It is not optimal from a risk standpoint for Square to have its fortunes tied to those of a cryptocurrency that has frequently displayed extreme volatility," wrote BTIG analyst Mark Palmer.
  • Shares of Square fell more than 16 percent Monday following Palmer's note.

Square's foray into bitcoin trading merely extends an "overdone" stock rally and puts off an impending correction, according to one analyst.

The company recently created a buzz with a trial that enables some users of the Square Cash app to buy and sell bitcoin, but this may be too risky for investors to stomach, said BTIG analyst Mark Palmer, who downgraded Square shares to sell on Monday.

The shares dropped more than 16 percent Monday, on pace for their worst day since May 2016, after the call.

"We believe Square's valuation already reflects emphatic and unimpeded growth while failing to factor in competitive, credit-related and macro risks that did not go away when some investors suddenly viewed its shares as a play on a trendy cryptocurrency," wrote Palmer on Monday. "We believe Bitcoin could provide a marginal contribution to Square's revenues if the trial succeeds, it becomes a permanent feature for all Square Cash users, and the company starts to charge a fee for trades."

He added, "It is not optimal from a risk standpoint for Square to have its fortunes tied to those of a cryptocurrency that has frequently displayed extreme volatility."

The analyst also cut his price target to $30, which is 39 percent lower than Friday's closing price.

Investors are already skittish when it comes to Square's stock.

With the company's shares up nearly 220 percent since January (as of Monday morning), anything less than perfect performance from Jack Dorsey's second major company tends to send the stock tumbling. Square handily beat Wall Street expectations in its latest quarterly earnings report, but its stock fell roughly 1.3 percent anyway.

After the company told investors about its plans to launch the bitcoin trading function on its Square Cash application, shares soared 11 percent as fascination with the cryptocurrency intensifies.

"It's dangerous for a stock to become tethered to a cryptocurrency," Palmer said on CNBC's "Closing Bell" later on Monday. "The other thing that happens when you see a craze along these lines is that investors forget about the risks — the other risks associated with the story. In this case, what we see with Square is they're getting increasingly involved in credit."

"At a time when PayPal is selling its credit portfolio to Synchrony Financial, Square is running into the fire."

Bitcoin surged over the Thanksgiving holiday, according to CoinDesk, and continued its relentless climb on Monday, last seen trading above $9,600.