Health and Science

Obamacare insurers see better financial performance in 2017, 'no sign of market collapse'

Key Points
  • Obamacare health insurers are showing "no sign of a market collapse'" despite Trump administration claims to the contrary.
  • The Obamacare market has continued stabilizing and insurers are regaining profitability, a new report says.
  • Sign-ups for individual health market plans were surprisingly strong at the end of 2017 despite undercutting of the market by President Donald Trump.
Isabel Diaz Tinoco (L) and Jose Luis Tinoco look at a computer as Otto Hernandez, an insurance agent from Sunshine Life and Health Advisors, shows them the different insurance plans available under the Affordable Care Act at a store setup in the Mall of Americas on November 1, 2017 in Miami, Florida.
Getty Images

Obamacare isn't failing. Again.

A new analysis of the financial performance of Obamacare health insurers finds "no sign of a market collapse."

That report instead finds that the Obamacare market has continued "stabilizing," and that insurers are "regaining profitability" despite continued political uncertainty over the health-care law.

It also found that the pool of Obamacare customers, while less healthy as a group than before the law took effect, showed no signs of becoming sicker in the latter part of 2017.

Obamacare enrollment numbers blow away expectations at nearly 9 million

"Data suggest that insurers in this market are on track to reach pre-[Affordable Care Act] individual market performance levels," said the report, prepared by analysts from the Kaiser Family Foundation.

The report, comes on the heels of surprisingly strong enrollment on the federal Obamacare marketplace during the recently concluded open sign-up season.

The Trump administration, which opposes Obamacare, had taken a series of steps that experts believed would markedly depress the number of sign-ups for individual health plans this year.

President Donald Trump also has repeatedly said that Obamacare is "failing," and needs to be substantially replaced with new health-care legislation.

The administration so far has failed to undo the law, although it won effective repeal, starting in 2019, of the mandate that most people have some form of health insurance or pay a tax penalty. The repeal was part of the new tax law passed by Congress in December.

And only about 500,000 fewer people signed up on the federal Obamacare exchange than did last year, with 8.7 million people in 39 states enrolling. Sign-ups in the remaining states not served by are as a group seeing significantly higher enrollment for 2018.

Kaiser's report noted that the financial performance of insurers who sell individual health plans like those on Obamacare exchanges worsened in 2014 and 2015, the first two years that exchange-sold coverage was in effect. Those were the first years that the Affordable Care Act barred insurers from charging less-healthy people higher premiums, or denying them coverage altogether.

But that financial performance "showed signs of improving in 2016 and stabilizing in 2017 as insurers began to regain profitability," the report said.

For its analysis, Kaiser's staff looked at recently released data through the end of the third fiscal quarter of 2017.

In 2017, Kaiser said, insurers' so-called medical loss ratios saw "significant improvement."

A medical loss ratio compares the amount of spending on health claims for customers to the premiums paid by customers.

In the third quarter of 2015, Obamacare insurers on average reported medical loss ratios of 97 percent — meaning they were spending 97 cents for every $1 of premium they collected to cover customers' health costs.

That dropped to 91 percent in the third quarter of 2016.

And it dropped again to 81 percent in the third quarter of 2017, Kaiser said.

The report noted that overall annual loss ratios for 2017 are likely to be affected by the Trump administration's decision to stop paying, as of the fourth quarter, billions of dollars worth of reimbursements to insurers to offset discounts insurers give customers for out-of-pocket health charges.

The report also looked at the average gross margins per Obamacare customer per month.

By that metric, "insurer financial performance improved dramatically through the third quarter of 2017," the report found.

As of that quarter, the average gross margin was $79 per enrollee. That compares to just $10 per enrollee in the third quarter of 2015.

The Kaiser report said that the sharply higher premium increases seen in 2017 are driving the improved financial performance among insurers.

While premiums rose by an average of 17 percent per enrollee last year, per person medical claims grew by just 4 percent.

And those higher premiums do not appear, as some had feared, to have driven significant numbers of healthy customers from Obamacare plans, according to the report.

Kaiser said the average number of days Obamacare customers spent in a hospital through the third quarter of 2017 was similar to the numbers seen through the third quarters of the prior two years.

While the overall financial performance of Obamacare insurers is improving, Kaiser's analysts said "there remain some areas of the country that are more fragile."

"In addition, policy uncertainty has the potential to destabilize the individual market generally," the report said.

WATCH: Congress deals two big blows to Obamacare

Congress is dealing 2 big blows to Obamacare