If it's hard to believe that one fish could be worth a mind-boggling $2.6 million, then you're probably not familiar with the high-stakes world of tournament sports fishing.
The White Marlin Open in Ocean City, Maryland, is a week-long competition held annually in August and in the fishing world, it's basically the Super Bowl. This year's competition takes place Aug. 5-9 and billionaire basketball legend Michael Jordan's fishing boat, Catch 23, is registered to compete.
The prize money for last year's tournament ballooned to more than $5 million, making it the most super rich fishing competition in the world.
Every year the multimillion-dollar jackpot is divided across more than a dozen prizes. In 2018, it included a head-spinning $904,000 payout for the biggest tuna, a $924,000 prize for the largest blue marlin — and the $2.6 million mega-payout for the largest white marlin reeled in.
"This competition is no joke," Schwalbach said on the first day of the fishing tournament. "We're going to get him today — we're going to get a monster."
For his chance to pull millions of dollars out of the ocean, Schwalbach and the other anglers who competed had to pay-to-play, and the tournament fees aren't cheap. Entry fees start at $1,100 per boat and could reach more than $25,000.
"You're fishing at a pro level, you feel like you're an NFL player," said the New York-based CEO, who loves the sport so much he built a home in Ocean City so he could fish more.
He said between all the entry fees, hiring a captain, paying the crew, chartering a fishing yacht, plus all the fuel needed, the high-end fishing trip cost him about $45,000.
The high cost of entry means many anglers compete as a team, which means they can split all the costs — and if they win, the prize money, too.
"I have a lot more faith in myself as an angler than bringing bodies in to split the money," Schwalbach said.
All the cold hard cash that's up for grabs is enough to lure hundreds of participants, who journey to Ocean City for a chance to cast out a line and strike it rich.
More than 300 boats competed in 2018, so the chances of reeling in that $2.6 million white marlin were slim. All fish have to meet the tournament's minimum weight requirement. Then, assuming an angler on one of those boats catches a qualifying fish, the odds of winning were about 1 in 300, or less than 0.3%.
Schwalbach wasn't discouraged because he believed his odds were much better, since he's been fishing for over 50 years.
"Based on skill, I feel that my odds are 90% I win, 10% I can lose," he said.
As you might imagine, a tournament with so much money on the line has lots of strictly enforced rules.
"You're dealing with millions of dollars, and there are a lot of cheaters out there, so they [organizers] put polygraphs in there to keep everyone honest," said Schwalbach.
Competitors can only fish on three days of the five-day event. And while boats can leave the docks before sunrise to search for a spot to fish, no angler can put a line in the water before 8:30 a.m. sharp, and every competitor's line must be pulled from the water at 3:30 p.m. on the dot.
And while a boat can have more than one fisherman on board, once there's a bite and an angler takes the pole he or she must reel the fish in without assistance. In other words, no other angler can so much as touch the pole. Any violation of these rules and countless others can lead to an immediate disqualification without any refund of entry fees.
And since the competition happens up to 90 miles offshore where fishing is almost entirely unmonitored, any person who wins more than $50,000 may be, at the discretion of the directors, subject to a lie detector test to address any potential question of impropriety that may arise.
And if the polygraph reveals someone broke the rules, the results can be used to disqualify a contestant and even strip prize money.
How serious are they about the lie detector, you ask?
Two years ago, polygraph results suggested a competitor violated the tournament rules and those results were used to strip him of a prize worth more than $2.8 million. (The $2.8 million was later distributed to winners of other categories.)
When asked about the 2017 disqualification, Schwalbach said it was the right decision. "The rules are the rules and he was definitely not entitled to the prize money."
Over three days, CNBC cameras spent more than 30 hours with Schwalbach at sea, while he burned thousands of dollars in fuel and motored across hundreds of miles of ocean.
He reeled in some feisty white marlins, and cameras rolled as he fought to reel in what he thought was the $2.6 million fish-that-got-away.
Spoiler alert: While Roy did not end up catching the "monster" winning fish, here are the winners:
This is the $904,000 tuna that weighed in at 75.5 pounds and earned the fishing boat Buckshot the top tuna prize.
Here's the $924,000 blue marlin that weighed in at 881 pounds and was reeled in on Auspicious.
And this white marlin is the most expensive billfish in the world:
This $2.6 million prize-winning billfish weighed in at 83 pounds, earning Weldor's Ark the tournament's top prize. The marlin is worth about $31,325.30 per pound.
Despite not catching the big money fish, Schwalbach said he still had a blast. "It was an amazing tournament and probably one of the most fun in a lot of years."
If you're curious about what happens to all that pricey fish filet when the tournament's over, you may be happy to hear it was donated to Maryland Food Bank, an Ocean City nonprofit that helps serve needy Maryland residents, a spokesperson for the Open said.
"They donate all the food to the food bank, and I love that," said Schwalbach.
This article was updated to include Michael Jordan's entry into this years competition.
—CNBC's Christopher DiLella and Phillip Minton contributed to this report.