Macy's may not be the best stocking stuffer this holiday season.
The retailer, which is down nearly 80% from its 2015 peak, is set to report earnings Thursday morning. TradingAnalysis.com founder Todd Gordon says that retail carnage is likely to continue based on technical retracements.
"The rule that we use if you're looking at these retracements ... basically if you break the 78%, roughly three-quarters, if you don't hold that, the rule says you should retest the lows, and that's at $5," Gordon said Tuesday on CNBC's "Trading Nation."
Based on his technical analysis, when Macy's broke below that three-quarters retracement of its 2015 highs at roughly $20, that set it on a course back down to $5. Macy's would fall another 67% from its current price above $15 before reaching that level.
Looking at the technicals, Gordon doesn't see much hope for beaten-down Macy's but recommends a few other names with stronger qualities.
Quint Tatro, president of Joule Financial, isn't counting the retailer out and is hoping on a turnaround for the worst performing S&P 500 stock.
"Personally, I added some shares today. The stock is interesting here. I am not normally a bottom-fish trader. I don't try to catch falling safes, but the stock is trading like it's going out of business," Tatro said during the same segment.
Tatro points to Macy's fundamentals and says investors would assume the company couldn't cover their dividend.
"In reality, they're set to earn around $2.50 next year, with $1.50 in dividends, so that's covered. Debt to equity of 0.75, it's not atrocious. And it's got a current book value of around $20. So, the stock looked like it was bottoming," Tatro said.
Tatro said he won't add any more to his portfolio until he sees a dramatic turnaround in earnings growth and fundamentals.
"Ultimately, from a technical perspective, it's got to break back above $17," he said.
Disclosure: Tatro owns shares of Macy's