Personal Finance

Why now might be a good time to save in a Roth 401(k) or Roth IRA

Key Points
  • Roth accounts may make more sense than traditional, pre-tax ones when savers believe their tax rate is lower now than it will be in retirement.
  • Low historical income-tax rates and a large U.S. budget deficit make it likely tax rates will increase in the future, according to some tax policy experts.
  • It may make sense to split contributions 50-50 to Roth and pre-tax accounts.
Jason York | Getty Images

It may be a better time than ever to save in a Roth retirement account.

A Roth 401(k) plan or Roth individual retirement account allows savers to stash away money after it's been taxed, meaning Uncle Sam won't take a bite when retirees withdraw their funds later. Contributions to a "traditional" or pre-tax account — the other choice for retirement savings — are taxed upon withdrawal, instead of upfront.

Roth funds, therefore, may make more financial sense for savers who expect to pay a higher income tax rate in retirement relative to what it is now. Given current economic and political dynamics, a Roth account may make sense for more Americans than in past years.

"The only way to go is up," Steve Rosenthal, a senior fellow at the Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center, said of future tax rates in the U.S.

Cramer: To Roth or not to Roth? Untangling the IRA, 401(k) Roth mystery
Cramer: To Roth or not to Roth? Untangling the IRA, 401(k) Roth mystery

The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, the first major overhaul to the tax code in three decades, reduced income-tax rates for individuals to near-historical lows, Rosenthal said.

The law, signed in 2017, lowered the top marginal income-tax rate for individuals to 37% from 39.6%, for example.

Coupled with those historically low tax rates is the country's large budget deficit. The federal government's deficit swelled to nearly $1 trillion in 2019, due largely to spending increases and a reduction in revenues caused by the recent tax law.

The U.S. currently runs a budget deficit that is larger, as a share of its economy, than that of the three dozen other developed countries in the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development.

Some tax policy experts and financial advisors believe the deficit situation is unsustainable and will necessarily lead to tax increases in the future to bring in more money to run the government.

"One of the issues is this giant economic storm that's brewing in the form of this debt monster," said Leon LaBrecque, a financial advisor and CPA at Sequoia Financial Group. "There is going to be some pressure — both economic and cultural — to raise taxes."

Roth accounts would shelter savers from increases to the income tax rate. However, they wouldn't protect savers from non-income taxes such as a consumption tax or wealth tax.

Nearly 18% of U.S. households have a Roth IRA, representing an aggregate $800 billion in total such assets nationwide, according to the Investment Company Institute. By comparison, 26% of households have a traditional IRA, with a total $7.5 trillion.

More employers are beginning to offer Roth 401(k) accounts to their workers, who are adopting them in greater numbers. Nearly a quarter of 401(k) participants use a Roth account, a 30% increase in three years, according to the Plan Sponsor Council of America.

Due to a quirk in the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, income-tax rates for individuals are scheduled to increase to pre-law levels beginning in 2026, unless lawmakers extend them — which some tax experts view as unlikely.

Why every millennial should have a Roth IRA
Why you need a Roth IRA

Saving in a Roth account now, while tax rates are still low relative to what they will likely be in six years, could make a lot of sense, LaBrecque said.

More from Personal Finance
You might get a tax surprise if you use this account to repay student loans
This is why filing your income tax return will never be the same
Here's how the new retirement legislation could fall short

However, some experts believe savers shouldn't be trying to game the system by choosing between a Roth and pre-tax account, since it's impossible to know how lawmakers will change tax rates in future years. And there's always the possibility, however unlikely, that Congress could seek to tax Roth accounts down the road if the government's fiscal situation becomes dire.

"We can't predict future tax rates, but we can tax-diversify, hedging our bets by dividing savings between Roth and traditional," said Mark Iwry, a nonresident senior fellow at the Brookings Institution and former senior advisor to the Secretary of the Treasury during the Obama administration.

One strategy savers could use is a 50-50 split between both accounts.

Here's how much you should have in retirement at every age
Here's how much money you should have saved