Health and Science

Orthodox Jewish funeral that drew thousands was 'absolutely unacceptable,' NYC mayor says

Key Points
  • Mayor Bill de Blasio said a Hasidic rabbi's funeral that drew thousands of mourners in Brooklyn "was absolutely unacceptable."
  • De Blasio and NYPD Commissioner Dermot Shea said they are done warning people who violate social distancing guidelines and will start issuing summonses or arrest violators. 
  • Jewish organizations blasted the mayor's comments.
VIDEO5:0005:00
Orthodox Jewish funeral gathering was 'absolutely unacceptable', says Mayor Bill de Blasio

New York Mayor Bill de Blasio said Wednesday a funeral for an ultra-Orthodox rabbi that drew thousands of mourners in Brooklyn "was absolutely unacceptable," and he warned that police will start issuing summonses or arrest violators at similar gatherings. 

"It was a large gathering, again, tragically thousands of people. The amount of danger created by that kind of gathering is inestimable," de Blasio said at a press conference. "People will die because of it, which goes against everyone's values."

Jewish organizations blasted the mayor's comments.

Police didn't issue any citations at Tuesday night's funeral for Rabbi Chaim Mertz, but that will change, a police spokesperson said. De Blasio and NYPD Commissioner Dermot Shea said they are done warning people who violate social distancing guidelines. The rabbi died of Covid-19 at age 73, NBC New York reported.

Shea said "probably several thousand people" gathered on one block for the funeral, which was broken up by the NYPD. 

"That event last night never should have happened, it better not happen again," Shea warned. "You are putting my cops' lives at risk and it's unacceptable."

On Tuesday night, de Blasio sent police to Brooklyn where a massive crowd of people could be seen in the streets attending the funeral. The mayor sent a series of tweets scolding the gatherers, saying he went to the scene himself to ensure the crowd dispersed. 

De Blasio said he understood the instinct to gather and mourn, but he has now instructed the NYPD to take a "zero tolerance" policy to large gatherings.

The mayor's actions, however, also drew criticism on Twitter for singling out the Orthodox Jewish community.

Jonathan Greenblatt, CEO of the Anti-Defamation League, said the mayor's comments were "outrageous, especially when so many are scapegoating Jews."

The American Jewish Committee tweeted: "We deserve better from our leaders than generalizations and fingerpointing."

The Orthodox Jewish Public Affairs Council accused the city of having a double standard because police did not break up large gatherings of spectators viewing the Navy's Blue Angels and the Air Force's Thunderbirds honoring essential workers on the same day as the funeral.

 

Sen. Ted Cruz, R-Texas, said "Laws should be enforced neutrally (without) targeting religious faith."

De Blasio said he wasn't singling out the Jewish community for scorn, adding that "there will be no large gatherings of any kind, anywhere."

"We are talking about thousands of people in close proximity in one site. We will never ever allow something like that to go unchecked anywhere," he said.