Vice President Mike Pence wears coronavirus mask at General Motors plant after criticism for Mayo Clinic visit

Key Points
  • Vice President Mike Pence wore a mask while touring a General Motors plant in Indiana that is making ventilators.
  • Pence's visit came after he sparked criticism for failing to wear a mask during a tour of the Mayo Clinic despite that facility requiring masks for everyone there because of coronavirus restrictions.
  • President Donald Trump, who tapped Pence to lead the White House coronavirus task force, has refused to wear a mask, even as federal health officials urge Americans to take such precautions against the virus that causes Covid-19.

In this article

VP Mike Pence wears mask to tour GM ventilator plant
VP Mike Pence wears mask to tour GM ventilator plant

Vice President Mike Pence wore a mask while touring a General Motors plant that is manufacturing ventilators on Thursday, two days after igniting a storm of criticism for failing to put on a mask during a visit to the Mayo Clinic despite strict coronavirus restrictions requiring them there.

Pence was accompanied during the visit to the GM facility in Kokomo, Indiana, by Transportation Secretary Elaine Chao, Indiana Gov. Eric Holcomb, GM CEO Mary Barra and White House Trade advisor Peter Navarro — all of whom were also wearing masks.

But at a roundtable discussion later during the visit, Pence removed his mask, as did other attendees, including Chao.

U.S. Vice President Mike Pence and CEO of General Motors Mary Barra visit the General Motors Components Holding Plant that is manufacturing ventilators for use during the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) outbreak, in Kokomo, Indiana.
Chris Bergin | Reuters

Pence, who once served as governor of Indiana, is leading the White House's coronavirus task force.

His tour of the recently reopened plant came two weeks after it began producing ventilators with Ventech Life Systems to deal with a shortage of the medical breathing assistance devices in the face of the coronavirus pandemic.

Brian Rothenberg, a spokesman for the United Auto Workers union, said that General Motors requires workers at the plant to wear surgical masks there except when they are eating lunch.

Pence has previously said that he does not need to wear a mask to prevent spreading an infection — despite federal health guidance to the contrary  — because he is tested regularly for coronavirus, and has been shown to be negative for it.

Health experts have disputed that idea, saying the tests are not always accurate and that there is a risk that Pence could contract the coronavirus between tests and pass it on unwittingly to others.

The Mayo Clinic has said it told Pence's staff before he visited there Tuesday that masks were required for all visitors, staff and patients at its Rochester, Minnesota, facility because of the coronavirus outbreak.

But Pence's wife, Karen, on Thursday said during a Fox News interview that he only learned of the mask policy after he left the clinic Tuesday.

"As our medical experts have told us wearing a mask prevents you from spreading the disease and knowing that he doesn't have COVID-19, he didn't wear one," Karen Pence said on "Fox & Friends."

However, Voice of America reporter Steve Herman, in response to another journalist's tweet about Karen Pence's comment, tweeted Thursday that he and everyone else who had gone on the trip with Pence to Minnesota on Tuesday were "notified by the office of @VP the day before the trip that wearing of masks was required by the @MayoClinic and to prepare accordingly."


Herman's tweet was echoed by Wall Street Journal reporter, Gordon Lubold, who tweeted: "... everyone in the entire Mayo Clinic had a mask on, everyone, and we were all told the day before we had to wear a mask if we entered the clinic."

The Washington Post reported Thursday evening that Herman, the White House bureau chief of government-funded VOA, had been told by Pence's staff that he had violated the off-the-record conditions of a planning memo that was sent to journalists before the trip to the Mayo Clinic.

The Post article said that the White House Correspondents' Association had told Herman that Pence's office had banned him from further travel with the vice president on Air Force Two. The Post said a spokesman in Pence's office later told VOA managers that "any punishment was still under discussion, pending an apology from Herman or VOA."

A spokeswoman for Pence did not immediately respond Thursday night to CNBC when asked about Herman.

The federal Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, in guidance issued in early April urging Americans to wear masks, says, "You could spread COVID-19 to others even if you do not feel sick."

Vice President Mike Pence visits with lab physicians and techs while touring Mayo Clinic facilities supporting coronavirus disease (COVID-19) research and treatment in Rochester, Minnesota, U.S., April 28, 2020.
Nicholas Pfosi | Reuters

"Everyone should wear a cloth face cover when they have to go out in public, for example to the grocery store or to pick up other necessities," the CDC says in its guidelines.

Others have criticized Pence for possibly putting other people at risk and at the least not acting like a good role model, during his visit to the Mayo Clinic.

Jamie Gulley, president of the SEIU Healthcare Minnesota union, which represents thousands of Mayo Clinic workers, in a statement said, "When Vice President Mike Pence ignores the safety policy and refuses to wear a face mask, he insults the hard work and sacrifice of all healthcare workers."

"Worse, he puts them, their patients, and their families at risk," Gulley said.

Dr. Vin Gupta, a pulmonologist and global health policy expert who is an NBC News and MSNBC contributor, told NBC News that even if you do not have symptoms of Covid-19 but are infected "and you're just having a conversation ... you can easily transmit the disease."

VP Mike Pence visits Mayo Clinic, but does not wear face mask
VP Mike Pence visits Mayo Clinic, but does not wear face mask

"The vast majority of individuals that we think are likely transmitters of the disease have no symptoms," Gupta said. "You basically have a bunch of people feeling great who think they don't need to follow the rules."

President Donald Trump early this month he personally would not follow CDC's guidance calling for people to wear masks in public, even as he announced those guidelines.

"I just don't want to wear one myself, it's a recommendation," Trump said at the time.

"Somehow sitting in the Oval Office behind that beautiful Resolute Desk, the great Resolute Desk, I think wearing a face mask as I greet presidents, dictators, kings, queens, I don't know, I don't see it for myself."

But later Thursday, ata White House event, Trump said, "I'd have no problem" wearing a mask during a trip next week to an Arizona mask-making facility depending "on the conditions" there.

"I'm supposed to make a speech. I just don't know — should I speak in a mask? You are going to have to tell me if that is politically correct," Trump said.

"If it is, I will speak in a mask," he said.

As of Thursday, there were more than 1 million reported cases of the coronavirus in the United States, and an official death tally from Covid-19 of about 61,000 people.