Personal Finance

Why the real unemployment rate is likely over 11%

Key Points
  • The official U.S. unemployment rate fell to 8.4% in August, from 10.2% in July. 
  • That number may significantly understate the true rate, however, according to some economists. The real figure may be higher than 11% when accounting for various factors.
  • That would mean the country is still in the throes of an unemployment crisis worse than any time in the post-Second World War era.  
People wait in their cars as they line up to collect unemployment forms in Hialeah, Florida.

The official unemployment rate fell to 8.4% in August as businesses continued emerging from broad shutdowns imposed early in the coronavirus pandemic, the Bureau of Labor Statistics reported Friday.

That's the lowest rate since unemployment exploded in April, to levels unseen since the Great Depression. It would also mean the official rate dipped below the peak seen during the country's last downturn, known as the Great Recession. 

But the true rate in August is likely much higher than the official figure — perhaps even exceeding 11%, according to labor economists.

The unemployment rate is a measure of joblessness in the country and is a rough barometer of financial hardship.

A rate above 11% would mean the country remains in the throes of the worst period of joblessness in post-World War II history. It would mean roughly 1 in 9 people who want a job and are able to work can't find employment.

Before the coronavirus pandemic, the highest post-war unemployment rate in the U.S.was 10.8%, set in 1982.

The August unemployment figure is also significant since it's the first snapshot of joblessness from the BLS since a $600 weekly federal supplement to unemployment benefits lapsed at the end of July.

More from Personal Finance:
One unemployed single mom's plight in the age of Covid-19
Second $1,200 stimulus checks are still on the table despite stalemate
Senate Democrats are pushing to undo the payroll tax deferral

Millions of workers haven't been getting any federal assistance for more than a month, leaving them with just their state-allotted aid, which generally amounts to about half of lost wages. Workers in some states typically get less, however.

A federal Lost Wages Assistance program created in early August by an executive directive from President Donald Trump adds an extra $300 a week for roughly five weeks, but workers in most states haven't yet begun receiving that subsidy. And thousands aren't eligible to get it at all.

11.1% unemployment rate

There are a few reasons the true unemployment rate for August is likely higher than the official 8.4%.

For one, there's been an ongoing data collection issue since early in the pandemic regarding furloughed workers.

The BLS determines the unemployment rate based on a survey of American households. People conducting the survey have sometimes misclassified workers as being employed but absent from work instead of unemployed on temporary layoff, according to the bureau.

Being absent from work — a category that includes people on vacation or on sick leave, for example — doesn't boost the unemployment rate. A temporary layoff, or furlough, however, does increase it.

Economist highlights job growth inequalities in August employment report

The unemployment rate would have been about 0.7 percentage point higher than reported in August — or about 9.1% — if this misclassification error hadn't occurred, according to the bureau.

The true figure would have been larger still when accounting for people who dropped out of the labor force, economists said.

Such individuals may have been discouraged from looking for work due to the lackluster state of the job market, or may not have been able to look for work because of health concerns or child-care duties, for example.

This is important because the federal government doesn't count people as being unemployed if they're not in the labor force. To be counted as in the labor force, people must be available to work and actively looking for a job.

"One of the things many people seem to have missed is, the unemployment rate doesn't count people who aren't looking for work," said Michael Farren, an economist at the Mercatus Center at George Mason University.

There were about 164.5 million people in the labor force in February, before state governments shut down broad sectors of the U.S. economy. That figure fell by about 8 million, to 156.5 million people, in April.

"You didn't have 8 million people instantly decide, 'I'm going to retire instead of deal with this pandemic,'" Farren said. "That might have accounted for a small subset of that number, but most of that is people permanently laid off."

The size of the labor force has since recovered to 160.8 million in August — still about 3.7 million people less than the pre-pandemic figure.

If these people were counted as unemployed, the official unemployment rate would be 11.1%, Farren said.

That analysis is "static," meaning it doesn't account for other factors that may have influenced the size of the labor force, like high school graduates now looking for a job. That sort of "dynamic" analysis would likely raise the 11.1% figure a few additional tenths of a percentage point, Farren said.