Health and Science

A third dose of Covid vaccine may help protect immunocompromised patients, small study suggests

Akshay Syal, Erika Edwards
Share
Maryland National Guard Specialist James Truong (L) administers a Moderna coronavirus vaccine at CASA de Maryland's Wheaton Welcome Center on May 21, 2021 in Wheaton, Maryland.
Chip Somodevilla | Getty Images

A third dose of a Covid-19 vaccine may boost protection for some people with weakened immune systems, according to a study published Monday in the Annals of Internal Medicine.

The study, from researchers at Johns Hopkins University, included 30 organ transplant recipients, all of whom had been fully vaccinated with two doses of an mRNA vaccine, either Pfizer-BioNTech or Moderna. Because organ transplant recipients must take immune-suppressing medications to ensure that their body does not reject the transplant, there's concern that they may not develop robust responses to the vaccines, leaving them vulnerable to Covid-19.

Indeed, despite being fully vaccinated, the vast majority of patients in the study — 24 patients — had no antibodies against the coronavirus, and six patients had only low levels.

So, the researchers gave them a third dose of the vaccine, either Pfizer, Moderna or Johnson & Johnson. About two weeks later, their antibody levels were measured again. In patients who had no antibodies to begin with, eight had an increase following their third dose of the vaccine. And in the six patients who started off with low levels, all had an increase in antibodies against the coronavirus.

Read more from NBC News

Delta, now a 'variant of concern,' accounts for 10 percent of new U.S. cases, CDC says

Covid vaccines may not protect people with immune disorders. NIH trial seeks answers

More evidence suggests Covid was in U.S. by Christmas 2019

Though the study was small, the findings could be important for millions of Americans who are immune-compromised and still vulnerable to Covid-19, even after being vaccinated. According to the United Network for Organ Sharing, more than 17,000 transplants were performed in the first five months of 2021 alone.

"To me the main message here for transplant patients and immunosuppressed patients is a message of hope," said Dr. Dorry Segev, an author of the study and associate vice chair for research and professor of surgery at Johns Hopkins University.

That message has been received by organ transplant recipients such as Tamsin Skeels, 50, of Charlotte, North Carolina.

Skeels, who was not a part of the new study, underwent a liver transplant in September 2019, just a few months before the pandemic hit.

A few months ago, she got the Covid-19 vaccine under the guidance of her physicians.

But they cautioned her to remain vigilant about avoiding infection. "Don't change your behavior from quarantine," her transplant team advised, Skeels recalled. "Stay at home as much as possible. When you do go out, stay protected. Stay masked and stay distant, even after vaccination."

Even if the vaccines do not offer maximum protection for those with compromised immune systems, they can help indirectly when others get the shots.

"The more people that get vaccinated, the safer people on immunosuppressants will be," Skeels said.

Segev and his team had found in earlier research that only 17 percent of transplant patients mounted an immune response after one dose of a Covid-19 vaccine. After a second dose, that number rose to 54 percent, but that left 46 percent potentially unprotected.

"I'm pleasantly surprised" that some patients in the new study who hadn't responded to two doses were able to mount a response after a third dose, Segev said.

Still, as the study demonstrated, an additional dose may not work for every organ transplant patient. And it's unclear whether the same approach would work for other types of immune-suppressed patients, such as those with autoimmune disorders.

"We just need to figure out how to [protect these patients]," Segev said. "We need to know if it's going to be something as simple as a third dose or if we are going to need to do something like making immunosuppression changes in these patients." That could mean, for example, identifying which medications interfere with the vaccine response and modifying which are taken after transplantation.

Segev hopes to launch a larger trial to study how a third-dose booster regimen works in transplant patients across the country and is hoping to enroll 1,000 patients. For now, his advice to transplant patients is to remain cautious and practice public health measures such as masking and distancing when out in public.

"The mantra I'm telling my transplant patients is get vaccinated and act as if you are unvaccinated," he said. "I would do only what the CDC says is safe for unvaccinated people."

John Wherry, director of the institute of immunology at the University of Pennsylvania, called the study "strong" for helping to understand the immune response in immunocompromised patients.

Even though only one third of patients who hadn't responded to two doses went on to develop antibodies, Wherry was optimistic about what this means for transplant patients.

"This is a glass half full versus glass half empty kind of thing," said Wherry, who was not involved with the research. "One third is not zero, so it does offer some promise for people that are on immunosuppressant drugs."

Wherry cautioned that it's still unclear what the findings mean for real world protection for patients who are immunosuppressed and agreed that transplant patients and other people with compromised immune systems should be cautious before returning to normal social activities.

Skeels continues to be vigilant about mask-wearing and other ways of reducing her risk for infection.

"I know that there are brilliant people working on this, and I have confidence and faith and optimism," she said. "In the meantime, I'm going along as I did."