EPA and Scott Pruitt sued by groups alleging agency violated federal records laws

Key Points
  • Two groups sued the Environmental Protection Agency and Administrator Scott Pruitt on Thursday for allegedly violating federal records laws.
  • The groups claim the EPA has systematically refused to document "essential activities" and discouraged employees from keeping records.
  • Pruitt denied at least one of the allegations contained in the groups' complaint during a Senate hearing last month.
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) Administrator Scott Pruitt.
Saul Loeb | AFP | Getty Images

A watchdog group and a nonprofit that represents public sector employees are suing the Environmental Protection Agency and its polarizing administrator for allegedly violating federal records laws.

Administrator Scott Pruitt and senior officials at the EPA have sought to prevent internal conversations from being documented as required by law, the groups claim in a complaint filed on Thursday with the U.S. District Court in Washington, D.C. They say the EPA has systematically refused to document "essential activities" under Pruitt, and higher-ups are creating a culture in which career employees are discouraged from creating written records.

These actions prevent Americans from obtaining records of EPA processes and decision-making through the Freedom of Information Act, according to Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington and Public Employees for Environmental Responsibility.

Senator Whitehouse confronts EPA chief Scott Pruitt over past comments about Trump
Senator Whitehouse confronts EPA chief Scott Pruitt over past comments about Trump

The EPA's failure to document has masked its process for overhauling major regulations like the Waters of the United States rule, the groups say.

"Under Scott Pruitt, the EPA has assumed a bunker mentality where paper trails are religiously avoided unless penned in invisible ink," Adam Carlesco, staff counsel for PEER, said in a statement. "By law, the American public has a right to know the basis for public health and anti-pollution decision-making that affects their lives."

The law in question is the Federal Records Act, which provides guidelines to government agencies on how they should create and maintain records of their activities.

A spokesperson for the EPA said the agency does not comment on ongoing litigation.

In their complaint, the groups cite news reports that Pruitt prefers to hold face-to-face meetings and avoids email to prevent his comments from being documented. They note that employees told The New York Times that Pruitt prohibits staff from bringing cellphones to meetings and discourages them from taking notes.

Pruitt said during a Senate oversight hearing last month that reports about the ban on note-taking at the EPA are inaccurate.

"I am very encouraging of the folks taking notes during meetings. Because I forget things often and we want to make sure we are keeping track of where we are heading on issues," he told the Senate Committee on Environment and Public Works.

The groups also point to the installation of a soundproof communications booth in Pruitt's office, which reportedly cost more than $25,000 and is the subject of an investigation by the EPA's inspector general.

Also named as defendants in the complaint are the National Archives and Records Administration and David Ferriero, the archivist of the United States. The groups claim the administration has failed to enforce the Federal Records Act by not taking action to investigate the EPA. Pruitt has defended the booth.

In an emailed statement to CNBC, a National Archives spokesperson said the Office of the Chief Records Officer of the United States has issued a formal inquiry and requested a response from EPA leaders to address the concerns raised by Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington.

"This matter is active and ongoing, and as is the case with all such allegations of improper recordkeeping, we consider each case seriously and expect that the agency complies with existing records management laws and regulations," said James Pritchett, the administration's director of public and media communications.

The latest lawsuit against Pruitt and the EPA comes as the administrator's travel habits are under increasing scrutiny. On Wednesday, South Carolina Republican Trey Gowdy, who chairs the House Oversight Committee, requested information about Pruitt's frequent first-class flights detailed in a series of recent news reports.

WATCH: Trump EPA to start rolling back Clean Power Plan

Trump EPA will start rolling back Clean Power Plan
Trump EPA will start rolling back Clean Power Plan