logo

Beware: These moves can leave a dent in your credit score

Key Points
  • These common moves can cause your credit score to drop.
  • They include closing a line of credit, paying an old debt and failing to regularly check your credit report.
ADragan | iStock | Getty Images

Many people are in the dark about what makes their credit scores rise and fall.

That's the takeaway from a new survey by the Consumer Federation of America and VantageScore Solutions, which found that consumer knowledge about credit scores is at the lowest level in the past eight years.

VIDEO2:0602:06
How a FICO credit score affects your life

"Consumers know less about credit scores but think they know more," said Stephen Brobeck, a senior fellow at the Consumer Federation of America.

The standard advice for a healthy credit score is to avoid paying your bills late or letting your balances get too high. Yet other moves — some seemingly positive — can actually lower your score, experts say.

Paying off an old debt
martin-dm | Getty Images

It seems like you're doing something good: An old, unpaid bill resurfaces and you make a partial payment on it.

However, sometimes these debts are already so old they're not legally enforceable, said Katherine Lucas McKay, who focuses on consumer debt at the Aspen Institute.

Once the debt collector makes a record of your active payments, it's legal in many states for the debt to be treated as new, Lucas McKay said.

More from Invest in You
Suzy Welch: What to do to get promoted
Save for retirement and pay student loans at same time
5 ways to switch careers without spending a dime

WATCH: 3 smartest things to do with an extra $1,000

Often the easiest thing to do, she said, is to pay off the balance completely. "Your score will start to rise again once that record is closed," she said.

If you believe the collection agency is acting inappropriately, file a public complaint through the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. For the debt collectors, she said, it's often easier to just resolve the issue "rather than have their regulator look into the situation."

Sticking with one type of credit
Kevin Dodge | Getty Images

Ten percent of your score is about the variety of your debt, said Matt Schulz, credit expert at CompareCards.com.

"If you've had a car loan, a personal loan, a credit card and a mortgage and handled them all well, you're probably going to have a higher score than someone who has just had a credit card — all other things being equal," Schulz said.

That's because lenders have more data points to pull from to make their decisions.

You shouldn't go out and get a loan you don't want or need just to bump your score a bit, he said, but, "it is worth considering in some circumstances."

Closing a line of credit
Credit card debt
Peter Dazeley | Getty Images

After you've paid off a credit card, you might close the line of credit.

Keep in mind that doing so will lower your overall credit limit, and therefore may increase your utilization rate — how much credit you're using versus what's available to you.

"There is some data from FICO that reveals people with credit scores above 800 commonly maintain a credit ratio below 10%," said Bruce McClary, vice president of communications at the National Foundation of Credit Counseling.

Sign Up for Our Newsletter Your Wealth

Weekly advice on managing your money
Get this delivered to your inbox, and more info about about our products and services.
By signing up for newsletters, you are agreeing to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

To offset the smaller credit limit, you should have a strategy for paying down the remaining balances as quickly as possible and bringing the utilization ratio back within an acceptable range, McClary said.

Also: Don't rush to open a bunch of new cards at once. Doing so can lower your score.

Failing to check your credit report

Errors on your credit report can drag down your score, Schulz said. "It's absolutely essential to review your credit report at least once a year to make sure that it is accurate," he said.

If you see a potential problem — be it a reporting issue or sign of identity theft or fraud, let the credit reporting company know as soon as possible. "The resolution process probably won't be fast or simple," Schulz warned. "But it's all worth it.

"You should never let someone else's mistake damage your finances."

The three big firms that generate credit reports for consumers are Experian, Equifax and TransUnion. You are allowed one free report from each of the three companies each year, according to the Federal Trade Commission.

You can also freeze your credit with these agencies for free to protect yourself from identity theft and other types of fraud.

VIDEO1:0301:03
Here are the 3 smartest things to do with an extra $1,000