Personal Finance

Here's why getting a raise can actually hurt your retirement

Key Points
  • Raises, and how we spend them, can make it more difficult to retire comfortably, according to a new report. 
  • "Lifestyle creep" and stagnant savings rates could cause a lower standard of living in one's golden years. 
  • The "spend twice your years to retirement" rule of thumb can help guide financial decisions around a raise. 
Hill Street Studios

Here's a head-scratcher: Getting a raise could hurt your standard of living in retirement.

That conclusion seems counterintuitive. After all, wouldn't saving the same percentage of a larger paycheck yield more savings, and therefore a healthier retirement?

Not exactly, according to new research published by Morningstar.

"Raises — and how we spend them — can actually make it more difficult to retire comfortably," the report said.

That's partly due to something called "lifestyle creep."

More from Personal Finance:
Tax season is here! What you need to make it easy
Supreme Court could upend consumer financial protection
The secret to financial success: Paying off debt

Getting a raise may make things previously out of financial reach seem more affordable. But paying for that new car, larger house or bigger apartment locks in larger monthly bills.

Unless Americans increase their savings by an appropriate amount, they won't be able to fund these bigger expenses in retirement as easily.

"It's not a one-off thing," said Steve Wendel, Morningstar's head of behavioral science and one of four co-authors of the report, called "More Money More Problems." "It's a continuing bill – you have to continue paying for this new lifestyle."

A person's existing retirement savings and Social Security benefits also typically stay static or grow more slowly than income does after a raise. They may actually "shrink" relative to new retirement needs, according to Morningstar.

For example, Social Security benefits increase with wages, but only to a certain amount.

Five things you should do when you get a raise at work
What to do when you get a raise at work

Americans also typically don't change their savings rates after receiving a raise. This strategy — saving 10% of a paycheck both before and after getting a bump in pay, for example — isn't smart, according to the report.

Instead, savings rates should generally increase with wages, researchers argue.

"People by and large aren't increasing their contributions when they get a raise," Wendel said. "It's not something many Americans do."

Luckily, there's a rule of thumb people can use to make sure they're saving an appropriate amount of each pay increase: Spend twice your years to retirement.

A saver would double their years left to retirement and could safely spend that percentage of their raise, while saving the rest.

Here's how much you should have in retirement at every age
Here's how much money you should have saved

A 35-year-old could spend 60% of a raise and save the remaining portion. A 50-year-old could spend 30% and save the remaining 70%. (These examples assume a retirement at age 65.)

However, savers should only use this framework, derived from an analysis of the Survey of Consumer Finances, as a good starting point — especially if they're unlikely to get a more detailed analysis from a financial advisor, researchers caution.

Older savers will likely have to set aside more of their raises than their younger counterparts, too — regardless of how well-funded the household is for retirement, according to Morningstar.

Older people have less time to save for retirement, and their savings have less time to appreciate.

Suzy Welch: This is the biggest mistake people make when negotiating salary
Suzy Welch: This is the biggest mistake people make when negotiating salary