Personal Finance

Stocks may be in trouble. Should you turn to bonds?

Key Points
  • Troubling headlines about the stock market of late may be prompting investors to give bonds another look.
  • Here's a look at what experts say you should weigh.

In this article

Vlad Yushinov | iStock | Getty Images

The stock market has taken some steep drops this month, and forecasts of a correction, or worse, are mounting.

As a result, many investors may be wondering if it's time to transfer some of their money to bonds, where returns can still be decent but the risk of losses is typically lower than with equities.

"My outlook on bonds remains that they serve a critical role of shock absorber when stocks tank," said Allan Roth, a certified financial planner and founder of Wealth Logic in Colorado Springs, Colorado.

Indeed, portfolios weighted heavier in bonds tend to recover faster from downturns than ones tilted more toward stocks.

More from Personal Finance:
Democrats want to ax the backdoor Roth IRA strategy
Worried about inflation? Here's how to protect your retirement portfolio
Retirees worried about stocks cratering can use these portfolio strategies

An allocation with more than 70% stocks and the rest in bonds and cash took more than two years to recover from the 2008 financial crisis, compared with just seven months for portfolios with more than 70% in bonds and cash and the rest in stocks, according to calculations provided by Charles Schwab.

But not all bonds will protect you during troubling times, experts say.

"High-yield bonds are highly correlated with equities," said Stuart Katz, chief investment officer at Robertson Stephens in San Francisco.

Instead, Roth recommends a fund such as the Vanguard Total Bond Fund, which is made up of roughly 65% U.S. government bonds.

"And only the U.S. government can print money," he said.

Bond market shows there's concern about growth: Investor
Bond market shows there's concern about growth: Investor

Recently, Eric Jacobson, a strategist at Morningstar, found that even though U.S. Treasury bonds have returned investors just around 3% a year over the past decade, they make up a quarter or more of many of the bond funds tracked by Morningstar.

That's because when the markets sour, these bonds tend to act as an insurance policy.

For example, when the S&P 500 Index was down by more than 20% between February and March 2020, a 10-year Treasury note was up 8%, according to calculations by Jacobson.

"Back in 2008, when we had the financial crisis, the only thing that saved a lot of people were their bond allocations," Jacobson said.

Still, experts caution against getting too jittery.

Keeping too much of your money in bonds or cash can be just as risky as investing too much of it in the market.

The S&P 500 has outpaced the Morningstar Core Bond Index in nearly every three-month rolling period over the past 10 years, Jacobson found.

Even those nearing or in retirement benefit from remaining in the market. In fact, Wade Pfau, professor of retirement income at the American College for Financial Services, says retirement portfolios last longest when stock ownership ranges between 50% and 75%. 

Meanwhile, bonds come with their own risks these days.

"Bonds are facing a lot of headwinds with the threat of rising inflation and a possibility of increasing interest rates," Katz said.

Inflation is not transitory: Strategas CEO Jason Trennert
Inflation is not transitory: Strategas CEO Jason Trennert

In response, investors may want to take a second look at bonds that go up with inflation, such as Treasury inflation-protected securities, or TIPS, and Series I bonds, said Andy Mardock, CFP and founder and president of ViviFi Planning in Bend, Oregon.

Owning bonds with a variety of maturity dates will also enable investors to move around their money and take advantage of increasing interest rates, he said.

Overall, when determining their allocation between stocks and bonds, investors should prioritize their own financial goals and time horizon over current economic conditions, Mardock said.

"The right allocation for any investor is a calculated assessment of the risk and return that makes sense for them," he said.