Did Barack Obama Just Mandate An Ex-Pat Package?

President Barack Obama lashed out a “modern slavery” during his speech to the Clinton Global Initiative Tuesday, announcing a new executive order expressly banning U.S. government contractors from engaging in human trafficking.

U.S. President Barack Obama speaks during the annual meeting of the Clinton Global Initiative (CGI) in New York, U.S., on Tuesday, Sept. 25, 2012.
Jin Lee | Bloomberg | Getty Images
U.S. President Barack Obama speaks during the annual meeting of the Clinton Global Initiative (CGI) in New York, U.S., on Tuesday, Sept. 25, 2012.

The contrast with Mitt Romney’s speech earlier in the day was notable.

Where Romney stuck to the broad outlines of his plan for foreign policy, Obama came to the podium with a very specific policy announcement. It’s even got its own fact sheet. No doubt this was intentional — we were meant to notice. (More:Hillary Clinton: Raise Taxes on the Rich Everywhere)

But one of the problems with coming to the table with specifics is that this tactic opens you up to criticism. Obama’s executive order, for example, seems to overreach. It creates a bunch of new requirements for U.S. companies doing business with the government, requirements they will have to fulfill even in circumstances far removed from human trafficking.

As I read the executive order, for example, it requires government contractors to pay for the return trip when work is done internationally. For many types of expatriate work for government contractors, I would think the arrangement about who pays for transportation should be a matter of negotiation rather than regulation. Now it seems, at the very least, employees who don’t want their employer picking up the return ticket home will probably have to sign some kind of official waiver. (More:The UN's Idea of Freedom, and Ours)

This isn’t fatal to Obama’s program. A bit more bureaucracy and paperwork may just be the price we need to pay for making progress against human trafficking. But it is worth our attention to notice that yet again our well-meaning policy goals come festooned with trails of red tape.

- by CNBC senior editor John Carney

CGI 2012

  • Barak Obama, Mitt Romney

    It's not known exactly what the presidential candidates will talk about, but the theme of this year’s conference is decidedly non-political. In fact, it's downright world-builder-y: "Designing for Impact."

  • Former US President Bill Clinton during the Clinton Global Initiative (CGI) in September 2008 in New York.

    Not long ago, most American companies were urged by the U.S. government to avoid doing business with Libya. It was a pariah state, a sponsor of terrorism, a sworn enemy of the West. But former President Bill Clinton asked the chief executive of Wal-Mart if he would open a store in Libya.

  • Hillary Clinton

    Free-market types will urge freer markets, even when these take the form of the kind of corrupt privatization that gave rise to Russia's oligarchs. And the Obama administration, well, it thinks the wealthy need to be taxed more — everywhere.

Latest Special Reports

  • Innovative female entrepreneur examining prototype

    In an era of rapid technological advances and demographic change, how do legacy companies adapt, innovate and evolve? CNBC Evolve features iconic global companies and executives who are embracing change and transforming for the future.

  • working together

    CNBC Upstart 100 is a new original list of the bright young startups poised to become the great companies of tomorrow.

  • A look at 50 private companies set to reshape the business landscape.

U.S. News