The Buffett Challenge, hedge funds vs. index funds, 9 years on

  • After nine years, hedge fund portfolios are up 22 percent on average, compared to 85.4 percent for Warren Buffett's Vanguard Admiral Shares S&P 500 Index Fund pick.
  • Three of the five hedge funds have average annualized returns of less than 1 percent.
  • Buffett's charity beneficiary looks set to get account funds come Dec. 31, 2017, as the Oracle of Omaha's bet outperforms Protege Partners' five undisclosed hedge funds.

Nearly 10 years ago Berkshire Hathaway CEO (and arguably one of the best investors on Earth), Warren Buffett, issued a challenge to the hedge fund industry — a $1 million bet that they could not put together a portfolio of hedge funds that would outperform an S&P 500 Index fund over a 10-year period.

Buffett was convinced the combination of active stock-picking and high costs would result in lagging market performance, and he was willing to put his money where his mouth was.

One company stepped up to the challenge. Protégé Partners LLC selected five hedge funds (the names of the funds have not been disclosed publicly), and Buffett selected the Vanguard Admiral Shares S&P 500 Index Fund.

Hedge funds vs. index fund

The 10-year period began January 1, 2008, which means we are in the final year of the challenge. While we don't know the funds selected by Protégé, we do have a nine-year performance update — and it's not pretty.

The hedge fund portfolio is up just 22 percent over nine years. That's slightly better than 2.2 percent per year. How did the S&P Index fund do? Oh, just a smidgen better. It's up 85.4 percent, or 7.1 percent per year on average. The results by fund are even more startling:

2008–2016 Cumulative Returns of Funds in the Buffett Challenge

Fund A: 8.7%
Fund B: 28.3%
Fund C: 62.8%
Fund D: 2.9%
Fund E: 7.5%
Hedge Fund Average: 22.0%
Index Fund: 85.4%

These are cumulative returns for the nine years, not yearly averages, and all I can say is "yuck." Not only is the hedge fund portfolio lagging the index fund by a wide margin, not a single fund that Protégé selected is outperforming the index fund. Only one even comes close, and it's still trailing by more than 25 percent. Three of the five funds have average annualized returns of less than 1 percent!

More from FA Playbook:
How to figure out if you'll be able to retire early
Why a 30-year mortgage may not be your best option
Investors clueless about impact of a possible market correction

The challenge period officially ends Dec. 31, 2017, and it would take something we couldn't really call a miracle for Protégé to win. It would take a catastrophe, a market meltdown that would dwarf the Great Recession of 2008–2009, an event that would be so detrimental to investors and fund managers that Protégé themselves must secretly be hoping they will lose. And even with such a disaster scenario, Protégé might still lose if the funds they selected didn't hedge away most or all of the market downturns.

How the Buffet bet is structured

My favorite part of this story is about the bet itself, which should provide only further embarrassment to Protégé and the entire active-fund industry. Not content to make it a simple bet — just put up a half million dollars each and make it a winner-takes-all bet — the two parties agreed to put up a smaller amount and invest the money in zero-coupon Treasury bonds with the intent of growing the investment to $1 million by the end of year 10. That amount was calculated to be $640,000, so Buffett and Protégé each put $320,000 into the account nine years ago.

It didn't take until the end of 2017 for the account to grow to $1 million. Interest rates plunged in 2008 and 2009, sending the value of the bonds way up, and the account reached $1 million in 2012! Currently, there's more than $1.8 million in the account, or about triple what was invested. That's much better performance than either Protégé's fund portfolio or the index fund.

Untitled Document

Sign Up for Our Newsletter Your Wealth

Weekly advice on managing your money
Get this delivered to your inbox, and more info about about our products and services.
By signing up for newsletters, you are agreeing to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Lest you think the bet was about money, whatever amount is in the account at the end of the year will be given to the charity of the winning party's choosing: Girls Incorporated of Omaha if Buffett wins, or Friends of Absolute Return for Kids if Protégé wins.

Interestingly, Protégé did what they do best before the bet period even began — they hedged! They wrote back in 2007, "Hedge funds don't set out to beat the market. Rather, they seek to generate positive returns over time regardless of the market environment." A curious comment from a company accepting Buffet's challenge to pick a group of funds that will, well, beat the market.

(Editor's Note: This column originally appeared at

— By Steve Tepper, chief operations officer at Northstar Financial Planners

Contact FA Playbook


    Get the best of CNBC in your inbox

    Please choose a subscription

    Please enter a valid email address
    Get these newsletters delivered to your inbox, and more info about our products and service. Privacy Policy.

Financial Advisor summit videos

  • CNBC reporters, contributors, members of the CNBC Financial Advisor Council and others for instant reaction to the Federal Reserve's decision on interest rates, its assessment of the economy, and Chair Powell's comments to the media, and what it all means specifically to financial advisors as they navigate their clients through the second half of a challenging year. Featuring live look-ins to the press conference, real-time market analysis, polling and answers to attendee questions.

  • Countdown to the Fed's big announcement on interest rates with Melissa Lee and the Fast Money gang. The traders dig into what they want to hear from Chairman Powell, while laying out how they expect the markets to react today, as well as the weeks and months to come.

  • The Home Front: Preparing The Biggest Asset For Tougher Economic Times

    Real estate represents clients' biggest, most important assets. Home prices are high, but now interest rates are, too. Two housing experts will tackle a changing housing market, and how to manage clients through the change.