Personal Finance

Trump vs Biden on Medicare: How each wants to modify the insurance program

Key Points
  • Whoever ends up in the White House in 2021 will need to address the looming insolvency for the trust fund that supports Medicare Part A, experts say.
  • Both President Trump and presidential candidate Joe Biden want to reduce prescription drug costs, although their tactics differ.
  • Biden also wants to lower the eligibility age for Medicare to 60 from 65.
Katrina Wittkamp | Getty Images

About three weeks into Medicare's annual fall open enrollment, voters will choose who's going to occupy the White House starting in January.

While President Donald Trump has taken some steps to ease certain costs for Medicare beneficiaries and has proposed other changes, Democrat challenger Joe Biden has some ideas of his own for the healthcare program.

Regardless of who wins the election , challenges are at play.

More from Personal Finance:
Here’s how to pay for long-term care
How Trump and Biden would handle student loan crisis
Beware of snags during Medicare open enrollment

For starters, Medicare funding is under pressure due to reduced revenue coming in during the pandemic-induced economic downturn. Basically, the trust fund that supports Medicare Part A (hospital coverage) could be insolvent — i.e., its revenue would not be enough to cover expenses — several years earlier than 2026 as last projected, experts say. 

"That will require Congress and the next president to step in and make sure Medicare is able to meet its future obligations," said Tricia Neuman, executive director of the Medicare policy program at the Kaiser Family Foundation.

Additionally, the Supreme Court is scheduled to hear arguments in November — a week after the presidential election — in the case seeking to overturn the Affordable Care Act (aka Obamacare). While that law generally focuses on expanding health-care coverage to more Americans, it also made some Medicare changes that benefited recipients.

VIDEO4:2904:29
Retiring early: How much health insurance will cost

For example, the law added certain free preventive benefits to Medicare. It also eliminated, over several years, the spike in out-of-pocket spending on prescription drugs that some beneficiaries faced.

"It's not entirely clear how a full dismantling of the ACA would impact Medicare," Neuman said. "But there's a real risk that it would increase costs for seniors, be highly disruptive for health-care providers and exacerbate solvency challenges facing the Medicare Part A trust fund."

Aside from the challenges in place, here's what could be ahead.

Proposed expansion

Under current law, people generally become eligible for Medicare at their 65th birthday. The majority of the program's 62.5 million beneficiaries are that age or older (the rest are younger with disabilities or individuals with end-stage renal disease).

Medicare is not free. However, as long as you have at least a 10-year work history of paying into the program, Part A — again, hospital coverage — has no premiums. Part B, which covers outpatient care, does have premiums, and higher earners pay more. Part D prescription drug coverage is the same. Those two parts of Medicare are largely funded by premiums and general revenue (not the struggling trust fund).

And, there are other out-of-pocket costs like deductibles and copays. Many beneficiaries turn to private insurance companies for Medicare Advantage Plans or so-called Medigap policies to supplement their coverage.

Biden wants to lower the eligibility age for Medicare to 60 from 65, with optional enrollment in that five-year period. The funding for this change would come from general revenue.

The cost is an estimated $200 billion over a decade, said Marc Goldwein, senior vice president of policy at the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget. However, he said, the price tag could be much lower.

"My gut is that's a high-end estimate," Goldwein said. "Health-care coverage is pretty high already in that age group."

He also pointed out that Biden wants to create a public health insurance option and expand access to coverage through the health-care exchanges. Those options could end up being better for those folks than Medicare, he said.

Separately, Biden wants Medicare to cover dental, vision and hearing, all of which are currently excluded. For that, current beneficiaries can sign up for a Medicare Advantage Plan, which may provide some coverage.

Lower drug costs

Trump has taken several steps to reduce the cost of drugs, including lifting "gag orders" on pharmacists that prohibited them from telling patients there was a cheaper option for their prescriptions. He also capped monthly insulin costs, effective next year, for some Medicare beneficiaries.

The president also recently said he wants to send $200 payment cards to some individuals on Medicare to help them pay for prescription drugs. However, it's uncertain where those plans stand.

Biden also wants to reduce what Medicare beneficiaries pay for prescription drugs, notably by allowing the government to negotiate those prices — which is prohibited by law currently. The Congressional Budget Office has estimated such a move would save $456 billion from 2023 through 2029 (based on a House bill that would make the change).

If they are going to do something with health care, I'd start with saving Medicare Part A.
Marc Goldwein
Senior vice president of policy at the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget

At the same time, though, the budget office report noted that negative effects may include reduced spending on research and development.

Biden also would prohibit most drug prices from rising faster than inflation. 

A couple of his other preferred methods to lower drug spending by older individuals echo those proposed by Trump: capping out-of-pocket spending in Medicare Part D prescription drug coverage and allowing consumers to import prescriptions, with safeguards in place.

Experts caution that the most pressing matter for whoever ends up in the White House will be the trust fund's solvency.

"If they are going to do something with health care, I'd start with saving Medicare Part A," said Goldwein at the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget.