Trying to time the market is a losing game

  • It can be tempting to react to market up and downs, or to try to anticipate them — but don't.
  • The secrets to investing success? Get sound advice; practice faith, patience and discipline; and tune out the hype.
  • For financial success, it pays to invest your time, not just your money, in your portfolio.

If you are educated about the stock market, the term "timing the market" probably sounds familiar. It refers to the idea that investors should buy stocks low and sell them high shortly after. It's a smart, swift and painless method ... or is it?

You might compare this method to switching lines at the supermarket checkout when you see another one moving faster. That is, it was moving faster until you decided to change lines. Trying to time things out of your control so they work in your favor sometimes works, and sometimes it doesn't. Either way, it's very hard to predict.

Trying to time the markets is the most destructive thing you can do to a portfolio, say advisors.
alancrosthwaite | Getty Images
Trying to time the markets is the most destructive thing you can do to a portfolio, say advisors.

There are too many factors influencing the price of stocks and bonds; trying to predict what the market is going to do is extremely difficult. A smarter approach is to spend more time in the market by holding long-term investments rather than trying to time the market.

The investing strategy myth

A common myth about investing is that success is all about strategy, such as in timing the market. This myth is one reason why many people fear investing: They think it's only for experts who have learned systems and charts and spend all their time studying the markets and poring over reports. While timing the market is a novel idea, even professional traders, with all the training, tools and time at their disposal, regularly post losses. Some perform well for a while, but it's very difficult to consistently win over the long term.

Nevertheless, there is no shortage of people who claim to know how to beat the odds. You'll find dozens of stock alert services on the Internet, all offering to help you with timing the market. Be warned: If you are not an expert, the odds are very much stacked against you.

More from Investor Toolkit:
How to take advantage of market volatility
Investing with borrowed money can be a big win
Beware of online financial quick-fix stories

Go long-term instead

On the other hand, if you study the Dow Jones Industrial Average, you'll find there's never been a 20-year period during which the index has failed to grow. It moves up and down a lot, but investors willing to take a longer-term approach, an approach called buy and hold, have historically seen positive gains regardless of day-to-day market volatility.

Longer-term approaches are a better strategy. JP Morgan compiled some research showing the importance of this. They tracked the performance of a $10,000 investment in the S&P 500 over a 20-year period. It showed a healthy average return of 9.85 percent per year. But they modeled what would happen if the investor withdrew from the market temporarily and missed the 10 biggest days on the stock market for that 20-year period (just 10 days out of 7,304). The result was a reduced return from 9.85 percent to 6.1 percent, which means a decrease of $32,665 in gains. And the more days missed, the lower the gains fell.

Untitled Document

Sign Up for Our Newsletter Your Wealth

Weekly advice on managing your money
Get this delivered to your inbox, and more info about about our products and services.
By signing up for newsletters, you are agreeing to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Nobel laureate William Sharpe found that "market timers" must be right an incredible 82 percent of the time just to match the returns realized by buy-and-hold investors.

3 quick tips for portfolio success

  1. Get sound advice. Even if you've decided to buy and hold, you still need to know which investment opportunities are proven performers with a likelihood of continued strength. The right advisor will also help you to wisely diversify your holdings.
  2. Practice faith, patience and discipline. Markets rise and fall continuously, and when they're down it can be tempting to pull out. Commit to your long-term strategy, and stay the course.
  3. Tune out the hype. If you watch the markets every day and read all the opinions, it will drive you crazy.

Patience pays off

The tactics of timing the market are fraught with danger; history vouches for the fact that "time in the market" is the safer strategy. When it comes to your financial success, it pays to invest your time, not just your money, in your portfolio.

(Editor's Note: This article originally appeared at

— By Humphrey Thomas, CEO of HG Thomas Wealth Management

FA Hub

Latest Special Reports

  • Nashville skyline at dusk.

    The pandemic and the success of startup culture have sparked the emergence of new hubs for businesses outside of traditional power centers of New York, Chicago, Houston and San Francisco. These Cities of Success each have used unique characteristics – pop culture influence, clusters of great universities, friendly geography or forward-thinking local governments – to attract major companies and nurture an entrepreneurial community around them.

  • The Workforce Wire provides news and information on what employers and executives are doing to adapt to the ever-changing workplace.

  • More than ever, the hope for a sustainable world has gained traction among the next generation of businesses, policymakers and investors. CNBC’s Sustainable Future focuses on how smart investments, new ideas and tech innovation can generate commerce — and a world — with staying power.